09Mar2025

Discretionary vs Advisory Investment: Which is Right for You?

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in the vapa Swiss independent wealth management blog posts featured on this page are solely my own and do not necessarily represent the views of any institutions or organisations I may be associated with. These posts are intended to share personal insights and perspectives and should not be interpreted as official statements or positions of any affiliated entities.

Choosing the right investment approach is crucial. Some investors want complete control, while others prefer expert management. But which option suits you best? Let’s explore the differences.

What is Discretionary Investment Management?

Discretionary Fund Management (DFM) puts experts in charge of your investments. You set your goals, and they handle everything else. They track the markets, adjust your portfolio, and decide for you. As a result, you stay focused on your broader financial plans without daily investment management.

Pros of Discretionary Investment

No effort required – Experts manage everything.
Fast decisions – No waiting for approvals.
Professional risk management – Adjusts to market conditions.

Cons of Discretionary Investment

Higher fees – More involvement means higher costs.
Less control – You trust professionals to decide.

What is Advisory Investment Management?

Advisory investment management gives you professional advice, but you stay in control. With this approach, experts analyse the markets and suggest investment strategies. However, before any trades happen, you make the final decision. This way, you get expert guidance while maintaining complete control over your portfolio.

Pros of Advisory Investment

You stay in control – So no decisions happen without your approval.
Lower fees – Costs are usually lower than discretionary management.
Expert guidance – Get professional insights before investing.

Cons of Advisory Investment

It takes time – You must review and approve all trades.
Slower response – Market shifts can happen before you act.

Key Differences vs. Benefits: Discretionary or Advisory Investment?

Feature Discretionary Management Advisory Management
Decision Making Fund manager decides You decide
Time Commitment Minimal High
Fees Higher Lower
Control Low High
Market Responsiveness Fast Slower

Which Investment Suits You? Take the Quiz!

Want to know which investment style suits you best? If so, this quick quiz can help you find out in no time. Simply answer a few questions, and as a result, you’ll get personalised recommendations to match your needs.

Discretionary vs Advisory Investment

1. How much time can you spend on investments?

2. Do you prefer experts making decisions?

3. Are you okay with higher fees for convenience?

4. How do you feel about market changes?

5. Would you rather make every investment decision?

Final Thoughts: Making the Right Choice

Go for Discretionary Management if you:

✅ Prefer a hands-off approach – Experts handle everything for you.
✅ If you have a busy schedule, there is no need to monitor investments yourself.
✅ Need quick decision-making – Professionals react fast to market changes.

Choose Advisory Management if you:

✅ Want complete control – You make the final investment decisions.
✅ Enjoy research and analysis – Ideal if you like exploring investment options.
✅ Prefer lower fees – Advisory management typically costs less.

By knowing your needs, you can easily pick the best way to grow your wealth. First, choose a strategy that keeps you focused and speeds up progress. If you prefer expert support, discretionary management works best. On the other hand, if you want full control, advisory management is the right fit. Since both options have strengths, carefully weigh your risk tolerance and time commitment. In the end, a smart choice brings stability, growth, and confidence. 🚀

No votes yet.
Please wait...
A financial advisor explains the differences between discretionary and advisory investment to a client using a digital screen in a modern office.

Get Your Monthly Insights!

* indicates required


Please select all the ways you would like to hear from vapa.ch:

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails. For information about our privacy practices, please visit our website.

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices.